SOC 2 Type I vs Type II: Which Report Do You Need?
A SOC 2 report is an independent auditor's opinion on the controls a service organisation has, assessed against the American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) Trust Services Criteria. Customers, especially overseas ones, ask for it before they will trust a provider with their data. The first decision is which type, and that decision sets your timeline.
The short version
- Type I reports on the design of controls at a point in time. Type II also tests how they operated over a period.
- Security is part of every SOC 2 report. Availability, Confidentiality, Processing Integrity and Privacy are chosen according to what customers need.
- Only an independent licensed CPA firm can issue the report. A readiness assessment prepares you for it but is not an audit.
The two types compared
| Question | Type I | Type II |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Whether controls are suitably designed at one date | Whether controls were suitably designed and operated effectively over a period |
| Evidence needed | Policies, configurations and a snapshot of controls | Records collected throughout the period, such as access reviews and change tickets |
| Speed | Faster | Slower, because the period has to run |
| Customer weight | Often accepted as a first step | Usually what larger customers ask for |
| Typical use | First report while Type II evidence builds up | Ongoing annual assurance |
The five criteria
| Criterion | Status | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Security | Included in every report | Is the system protected against unauthorised access? |
| Availability | Optional | Is the service available as committed? |
| Confidentiality | Optional | Is confidential information protected as promised? |
| Processing integrity | Optional | Does processing happen completely, accurately and on time? |
| Privacy | Optional | Is personal information handled as committed? |
Choose criteria based on what your customers' questionnaires and contracts actually ask for. Extra criteria add audit scope and cost.
Frequently asked questions
Who issues a SOC 2 report?
Only an independent licensed CPA firm can issue a SOC 2 report after examining your controls. A consultancy, including a readiness provider, cannot issue one. Readiness work prepares you by finding gaps, building evidence habits and choosing scope, so the audit that follows is shorter and less painful.
Should we start with Type I or Type II?
If a customer is waiting and you have no evidence history, a Type I report is the faster first step. If customers specifically ask for Type II, plan for the observation period and start collecting evidence now. Ask your prospective customers which they accept before you decide.
Do we need all five criteria?
No. Security is included in every SOC 2 report. Availability, Confidentiality, Processing Integrity and Privacy are optional and chosen according to your services and what customers need. Including criteria nobody asked for widens the audit and increases cost without improving your answer to a security questionnaire.
We already have ISO 27001. Is SOC 2 redundant?
No, but much of the work overlaps. ISO 27001 certifies a management system, while SOC 2 is an auditor's report against the Trust Services Criteria with its own scope and evidence expectations. A gap assessment shows which controls and records you can reuse and which are new.